Have you tried IIRF or ISAPI_Rewrite ?
It seems that ISAPI_Rewrite is powerful, stable and worth using. Give it a try and check it yourself.
Dan had mentioned about using 'Helicon ISAPI Rewrite 3 LITE ' previously which had worked for him
Make sure you need to have higher hosting package like a VPS or a Windows Dedicated Server ( without Plesk control panel) if you want to use ISAPI Rewrite module.